tough-customer.txt BuBe wrote: BuBe has left a new comment on your post "CERN Cab Survysis poozle": your explanation is based on YOUR ASSUMPTION of a time frame - what happens if the normal time for the cab to go each way is only 15 minutes or a half hour or 3 hours? What if Tobee walks a 7 minute mile or a 15 minute mile? What if the cab is driving 35 mph or 90 mph? What if the cab gets a flat? ;) The thing that's important is that you're told it takes 20 minutes less time for the shorter trip. The cab's speed and Toby's speed are not important. Equivalently, how long it takes to go each way is not important. If we somehow learn the cab driver is a slowpoke we can conclude Toby's place and CERN are close together. If the driver is a speed freak, they are far apart. But this distance is irrelevant. Getting a flat is a possibility. Given CERN's recent track record (accelerator meltdown) we probably should have stated that this did not occur. My bad. Here's a different time frame: It's still true that the legs not taken take 10 minutes each way. Since the distance between Toby's and CERN is fixed, the below is describing a much slower cab driver. 1 pm <--------------------------------------------------------- 8 am ---------------------------------------------------------> 6 pm 12:50 pm ......<--------------------------------------------------- 8 am .......---------------------------------------------------> 5:40 pm PS - You're a tough customer. That's one of the things I like about you. TcT Posted by BuBe to Interpres at July 18, 2009 5:23 AM